Amended March 2006

The Departmental Honors Program at UNCW provides the opportunity for superior students to engage in an advanced individual scholarly project in a specialized area. Graduation with departmental honors is a signal honor that is recognized on the student's diploma. This booklet describes the guidelines and requirements of Departmental Honors which is under the oversight of the Honors Scholars Program. The booklet also contains, at the back, a sample title page and forms, and a checklist for the student and the faculty supervisor.

What is an Honors Project?

Honors work involves independent study under the supervision of a faculty member in the student's major field. This independent study should be outstanding scholarly work appropriate to the academic standards of the student's major discipline, and should be completed in two 3-credit hour semesters or three 2-hour semesters. The results of the Honors work are summarized in a paper and presented orally before an examining committee. Generally, students do their work in departmental honors in their last two semesters. However, a student may begin in the junior year. In fact, students should be encouraged to begin their Honors work as soon as possible. Two semesters is not enough time for some projects.

Content of a Departmental Honors Project

The specific project and its content and methods are the choice of the faculty supervisor and student. Research projects are appropriate in all disciplines. Other types of scholarly activity, such as artistic performances or exhibitions, creative writing, or applications of research, may satisfy the requirements of the project in some disciplines. In all cases, an oral exam and a written record, such as a research paper or project description, are required.

Eligibility for Departmental Honors

Students with at least 74 semester hours credit who have a quality point average of 3.2 or better on all college work attempted (including transfer hours), who have completed [will complete] at least 30 semester hours of work with a 3.2 or better quality point average at UNCW, and who are recommended by the major Department Chair are eligible to enter the Departmental Honors Program. Academic departments of schools may require a higher grade point average for eligibility for Departmental Honors in their discipline. Students determined ineligible to enroll may appeal the decision to the Honors Advisory Council through the director of the Honors Scholars Program.

Enrolling in the Departmental Honors Program

1. In the semester(s) before departmental honors work may begin, students considering departmental honors work should discuss project ideas with faculty members in the major department. A faculty supervisor and a topic for the project should be selected in advance of the student's formal application.

FORMAL ENROLLMENT PROCESS:

NOTE: ALL materials must be received in the Honors Program Office before the last day to register for classes in the semester in which enrollment in 499 work begins.

2. The student obtains Honors Program Application Form (DH-1) from the Honors Scholars Program Office and submits the completed form to the Honors Scholars Program Office. The director of the honors program notifies the student of his or her eligibility. In cases of a determination of ineligibility, the director advises the student of the possibility of appeal to the Honors Faculty Advisory Council.

3. Upon the determination of eligibility to enroll, the Honors Scholars Program sends a copy of the Application Form (DH-1) and a Permission to Enroll in Departmental Honors Form (DH-2) to the student's faculty honors supervisor for completion. Form DH-2 is a description of the project topic and the membership of the examination committee.

4. The student and faculty supervisor select an examination committee. It will consist of four faculty members including the faculty supervisor, two other faculty members from the student's major discipline and one faculty member from a discipline other than the major. The faculty supervisor completes form DH-2, obtains the signatures of the members of the examining committee and the department chair. The faculty supervisor then forwards DH-2 to the appropriate Dean for signature.  Committee members must be members of the UNCW Faculty as defined in the Faculty Handbook. However, at the recommendation of the faculty supervisor and the department chair of the student’s major department, Honors may approve one non-tenured (or non-tenure track) faculty or staff member who has particular expertise in the subject area for full membership on the committee.  Signatures on the DH-2 form by the chair and the faculty supervisor indicate recommendation.  The faculty supervisor must be a tenured (or tenure-track) faculty member in the student’s major area.

5. Upon approval, the Dean forwards DH-2 to the director of the Honors Scholars Program, who informs the Registrar to enroll the student in honors work. The Registrar records the enrollment and returns the completed DH-2 to the Honors Program. The Honors office sends a copy of the Permission to Enroll in Departmental Honors Form DH-2 to the student, the faculty supervisor, and the department chair.

6. The Honors Scholars Program director assigns an Honors Council member to the project to assist the process in its formal aspects.

7. After the first semester of 499, the Registrar automatically enrolls the students in subsequent 499 semesters. No additional paperwork is needed. Registration for 499 is not done through SEALINE.

Carrying out Departmental Honors

A. Roles and Responsibilities:

After enrolling in departmental honors (499) the student and faculty supervisor collaborate as appropriate to carry out the project. During the course of the project, the following roles and responsibilities come into play:

The Student:

Ultimately, the honors project is the student's responsibility. The scholarly work and written thesis are to be carried out by the student in consultation with the faculty supervisor. Please see the guidelines for the form of the thesis below. Though the faculty sponsor, the Honors Council representative and the Director of the Honors Scholars Program are available to assist the student at any point, it is the responsibility of the student to know and meet all appropriate deadlines.

The Faculty Supervisor:

The supervisor is responsible for guiding the student in the selection of a worthwhile and feasible project that can be completed in the time available. To ensure successful completion of a project, the supervisor should arrange for regular meetings, perhaps once a week, to discuss the student's progress. The supervisor should address failure to make satisfactory progress promptly. The faculty supervisor is responsible for setting the date of the oral examination and for determining the grade, but may consider the advice of the oral examining committee. If the committee members should change, the faculty supervisor should notify the Honors Office.

The Examining Committee:

The examining committee is responsible for: (1) reading the paper, (2) making constructive comments on the paper, and (3) providing a challenging experience at the oral examination.

The Faculty Representative of the Honors Faculty Advisory Council:

The faculty representative from the Honors Faculty Advisory Council serves as a consultant for both the faculty supervisor and the student during all stages of the Honors project. The representative is responsible for ensuring that all formal requirements of the Departmental Honors Program are met and in particular that the final copies of the honors paper meet described requirements. The faculty representative from the Honors Council should attend the examination, but is not normally an active participant in the examination unless he or she is also appointed as one of the four members of the Examining Committee on Form DH-2.

B. Completing the Project and Paperwork:

Scheduling the oral exam:

When the student has completed the scholarly work and written the paper to the satisfaction of the faculty supervisor, he or she will provide a preliminary draft to the examining committee 16 days prior to the examination date. This gives the committee members the opportunity to read the paper and make comments. The committee members will forward their comments to the student no later than ten days before the examination date. The final draft of the paper should be provided to the committee members no later than two days before the examination date. The oral examination should be held no later than the last day of classes in the semester that the student is to receive a grade for the honors project. The student may bring 3 copies of the title page (on 100% cotton fiber paper) to the oral exam for signatures.

The Oral Examination/The Bound Thesis:

A completed title page signifies completion of a successful oral exam. Three copies of the title page (one for each copy of the thesis, one for the Honors Office), each signed by the faculty supervisor and the members of the examining committee, as well as the Honors Council representative, are required.

Upon receipt of the two copies of the completed final paper and the title pages signed by the committee, the Honors Council representative acknowledges by his or her signature that the proper format has been followed. After the Honors Council representative approves the final bound copies of the thesis and signs the title pages, the student turns the copies in to the director of the Honors Scholars Program. The director acknowledges their receipt by signing the title pages and forwarding a memo to the Registrar indicating that all requirements for departmental honors have been successfully completed. One copy of the thesis is held in the Randall Library General Collection while the other remains in the Randall Library Archives.

The bound copies are due in the Honors Office by noon on the last day of exams. The student should schedule a brief exit interview with the director at this time.

Grading Departmental Honors:

The faculty supervisor assigns the grade for 499 work in the same manner as all other grades, through a grade sheet submitted to the Registrar. However, a grade for all six credits of 499 work is submitted one time only at the end of the last semester in which the student is enrolled in the Departmental Honors Program and only upon completion of all the requirements and requisite Departmental Honors forms. No grade is recorded prior to that time. In the first semester(s) of 499, a grade of IP (in progress) will appear on the student's transcript.

If the grade is B (3.0) or better, the Registrar records six semester hours of 499 honors work in the area of concentration with that grade. If not, the work will not count as honors; a student receiving a grade of B- or lower will be given no more than three hours of 491 credit and will not graduate with honors. Credit hours received for honors work are used in the calculation of the student's quality point average and the hours are counted towards the 124 required for graduation.

The Honors Thesis Paper

1. The paper must be typewritten, double-spaced, on one side only of 8 1/2 x 11 inch paper. The left margin, including the title page, must be 1 1/2 inch; the others must be at least 1 inch.

2. The parts of the paper should be arranged in the following order and form:

3. Two library copies must be printed on 100% cotton fiber paper. The UNCW Bookstore will ordinarily bind the two copies, at no cost to the student, in a transparent cover through which the title shows. If the thesis is too large to be bound by the UNCW Bookstore, the student should have the copies bound at the copy center on campus and Honors will cover the cost of binding. Please contact the Honors Office should this happen.

Sample Title Page

 

Suggestions for Honors Project and Oral Defense 

While the content and style of the honors project appropriately vary across disciplines, there are common features across areas.  The honors project represents a comprehensive scholarly work in the student’s major area.  By definition, it is more than a semester project or term paper, and thus goes beyond the scope of an independent study class (DIS) or regularly offered class in the student’s major.  While the honors project need not be a scientific research paper, this model may be useful for the student and the faculty member to follow in setting an outline, guidelines and parameters.  Individual departments are urged to discuss the content, format, and style of honors projects that would be acceptable and appropriate for that discipline.

Outline

The honors project typically involves extensive background research and reading regardless of the major area.  This may be reflected in an Introduction, Background, or Literature Review section.  The purpose, hypothesis or goal of the project should be clearly stated.  The student should describe how the project was conducted, as in a methods and materials section.  There should be a section for presentation of the “meat” of the project- whether that means statistical analysis of empirical data, the text of the musical score, the critical review of particular works of literature, a collection of short stories, etc.  In most cases, there should also be a discussion and analysis of the findings of the project with a section considering whether the goal(s) of the project were met.  In addition, a summary paragraph or abstract presented at the beginning of the honors paper is required (not to exceed 250 words).

Meetings

While there are not formal requirements for the faculty mentor and the student to meet every week, most honors project teams find it helpful to set a specific time to meet every week or every other week. In addition, while there are no formal requirements for what the student should have completed each semester he or she is taking 499, most students and faculty find it beneficial to set mid-project deadlines.  This helps identify problems before they occur.  You may find that there need to be changes to the project as originally proposed and as long as the faculty member and committee are in agreement about minor changes, no additional paperwork needs to be done.

Final Paper and Defense

            The student should not submit a draft of the honors paper to the faculty committee until the honors supervisor has approved the draft.  The student should have a supervisor-approved draft to the faculty committee 2 weeks before the oral defense date (which should be no later than reading day of the project completion semester).  The purpose of the lead time is to allow the faculty members a week to review the paper, give comments back to the student and supervisor, and then give the student time to make changes before the oral defense.

The honors council representative should review the supervisor-approved draft for general style format so that the student may make 100% cotton copies of the title page to take to the defense.  The student may use whatever publication style is appropriate for the discipline.  It is the responsibility of the student and faculty committee to make sure the student has followed the appropriate style for the discipline, and the student is responsible for proof-reading.

It is the charge of the faculty committee to provide feedback on the written paper and a challenging oral defense for the student.  While there is not one set oral defense format, most defenses use a format similar to that of a master’s thesis defense.  Here are some suggestions:

-         The student should present an overview of the project, either to a public audience or to the faculty committee alone.  Many departments schedule an open defense so that other students and faculty can hear a general overview of the project and then ask general questions about the project.  This is the most desirable format because it allows: 

-         the student to hone his or her formal presentation skills,

-         the student to develop slides or a multimedia presentation if appropriate,

-         other students the opportunity to see an honors defense,

-         faculty to become better acquainted with each other’s scholarship interests,

-         the department to ensure consistent standards for departmental honors projects.

 

-         After the overview, the committee should discuss the project and its implications with the student to ensure that the student can defend his or her work at a junior colleague level.  While this is meant to be a challenging experience for the student, if the student is well prepared, it can actually be an enjoyable intellectual experience!  

-         After the committee has asked all its questions of the student, the student should leave so the faculty can deliberate about the student’s demonstrated grasp of the project.  While grading the 499 hours is the sole responsibility of the faculty supervisor, the supervisor will typically ask for input about the paper from the committee who may make suggestions for improvement.  The signatures on the title page itself indicate that the student passed the oral defense.  In some cases, there may be extensive suggestions to the paper itself, and the faculty supervisor and committee may wait to sign the title page after those changes are complete.

Final Copies

Final copies of the paper on 100% cotton should not be made until after the oral defense, as changes may be necessary.  Cotton paper can be purchased at the campus bookstore or other office supply stores.  It may be more economical for two honors students to buy a ream of paper to use for the required cotton copies.  Students can take the paper to a copy store and have copies made- this is usually cheaper than having the copy store provide the cotton paper.

Once all signatures (except that of the Honors Director) are obtained, students can take the two required copies to the bookstore on campus for binding- two copies are bound at no charge to the student.  Typically this is a quick process and usually the student can wait while the binding is done.  The copies, plus an extra title page with original signatures, must be turned in to the Honors Office by noon of the last day of exams.

Grading

Only one grade is assigned for the 499 project- during the semester the project is completed.  Since the honors project spans at least two semesters, an IP (in progress) score is submitted by the registrar and shows on the transcript until the final grade is turned in.  This IP score does not affect the student’s GPA.  The honors project is graded using the same grading scale as other classes and so +/- may be used as appropriate.  Because the grade can only be released after the honors director notifies the registrar that student has turned in all bound copies of the project, the faculty supervisor should email or memo the student’s grade to the associate registrar- SEAWEB will not work for assigning the grade.

What Happens If…

GPA Requirements to Graduate with Departmental Honors

In order to graduate with departmental honors, a student must successfully complete the Departmental Honors Program and have a 3.2 quality point average over all college work at the time of graduation. A student who does not retain an overall average of 3.2, however, will still receive credit for the honors project, but will not graduate with honors.

Note: If the student intends to complete an honors project for August graduation, please contact the faculty representative from the Honors Advisory Council and the director of the Honors Scholars Program before the end of the preceding Spring semester to ensure that the representative will be available to approve the final paper.

Incomplete

If the student will be unable to complete the project as indicated on Form DH-2, the faculty supervisor should inform the faculty representative of the Honors Council and the director of the Honors Scholars Program as soon as possible and assign a grade of incomplete. Please inform the Registrar and faculty representative from the Honors Council and the director of the Honors Scholars Program as soon as actual completion date is known.

Withdrawal From Departmental Honors

If a student is doing satisfactory work but has to withdraw, the faculty supervisor may assign the student a letter grade (A, B, C, etc.) and credit for an appropriate number of hours (0 to 3) of 491 Directed Individual Study. The faculty supervisor will state in writing to the Registrar the reason for the change, and notify the director of the Honors Scholars Program.

Double Majors

Departmental Honors is earned in the student's major area, e.g., the student graduates with departmental (or University) honors in psychology. If a student is double majoring, honors can be earned in either or both majors. To earn honors in both majors, the student must complete two honors projects.

Interdisciplinary Projects

Sometimes a student is majoring in one discipline and conducting research in a related area. An honor's project may be co-chaired by faculty supervisors in both areas (e.g., history and English). If the student is majoring in history, the student will graduate with honors in history. Thus, the history professor must be noted as the student's primary chair (e.g., the person who receives the 499 grade sheet). If the English professor is playing a key role in supervising the research, then both professors should be noted as co-chairs on the DH-2 form and on the title page of the honors paper. (Chairs from both departments should sign the DH-2 form). Because the student is earning honors in history, there should be three history professors on the committee (counting the co-chair) and the English professor serves as the co-chair and outside major department committee member. The student may elect to have an additional committee member(s) from English (or another discipline).

Faculty Supervisor Changes

If the faculty supervisor changes after the student is already registered for 499, the chair of the department should notify the director of the Honors Program in writing.

UNCW DEPARTMENTAL HONORS

Quick Checklist for Student and Faculty Supervisor

___ Form DH-1 completed, signed and filed in Honors Scholars Program Office by student

___ Approved Form DH-1 copy sent to faculty supervisor

___ Form DH-2 completed by student, supervisor; signed by committee members, department chair, and Dean; returned to Honors Office by 9 AM on last day of drop/add.

___ Director of Honors Program informs registrar to enroll student in 499.

___ Do the Project!

___ Student/supervisor schedule oral examination

___ Three copies of Title Page signed by faculty supervisor, committee, and honors council representative; bound copies of paper turned in to Honors Scholars Program, director signs title page; memo sent to registrar; thesis filed in library

 

Email us!